Frost My Heart, LLC

Phone:  (740) 816-6544

Click here to edit title

Custom & Creative Baked Goods.  Delicious.  Artistic.  Unique.

Customer Testimonials

" First off, the look of my sons first birthday puppy party cake was phenomenal! Second, it was the best tasting cake my husband and I have ever had. We have eaten many birthday cakes and always mentioned they were either dry or flavorless or all sugar. NOT this cake. THIS cake was amazing and EVERYONE at the party raved and is still raving about it. I will never order cake from anyone else for any occasion!
- Rana Greene

"Beautiful and delicious cake! Will be ordering again in a couple of months!" 

- Kristen McDowell

" I ordered our first custom "Minecraft" cake for my nephew's 8th birthday. Karla made us a cake beyond our expectations!! My nephew was speechless. Customer service was great too...very convenient! We will definitely use Frost My Heart for our future cake needs.
- Stacy Jefferson

"Karla has made two cakes for us and both were amazing. You tell her what you want and she totally takes it to the next level and beyond. Always always amazes me. I have actually had her cake for breakfast and lunch the following day. That's how good they are." 

- Lindsey Riemenschneider

" Karla did such an amazing job with my daughter's Luau themed birthday cake a couple of weeks ago! Absolutely amazing to work with! She has a repeat customer in me for sure!"
- Deirdre Lamont

"I am a cake junkie and this is by far the best cake I have ever had!!"

- Courtney Stroupe

"Frost My Heart was amazing! Helpful with design process, patient with my prolonged decision making, and best of all ended up with a one of a kind, super yummy cake. We loved the cream fill! Highly recommend."
- Tiffany Legg
"Karla's work is amazing! She created a fabulous monster smash cake that exceeded my expectations! Her cake balls were beautiful and delicious too! Thank you for helping make my little man's birthday so special!"
- Sarah Fisher

"Karla also does charity events. She recently gave away 1/2 dozen mini cupcakes per winter coat for the homeless. Not only is she crazy talented but she has a big heart!"

- Susan Weber

" Beautiful yellow rosette cake for my birthday. And yummy!"

- Pam Kempen

" Had a 50th birthday cake made and it was fabulous! We had so many compliments on how nice the cake was and how good the cake taste!! Will order again!! Thank you!"

- Karlene Sykes

"Awesome!"

- Maggie Durst

"FMH exceeded our expectations with the very special cake she created for our son's birthday! I simply provided a general theme and Karla did an awesome job of turning that into a cake that our 2 year old LOVED! Everyone raved at how beautiful and yummy it was - will definitely order from FMH again!"
- Bethany Anderson
"Unbelievable talent with Frost My Heart! I ordered a two tier, woodland theme cake that I found on Pinterest and Karla's creativity, attention to detail and talent secured her as THE place for all my future cakes, cupcakes, cake pops plus dessert ideas in the future. Thank you Frost my Heart!"
- Courtney Neal-Osborne
"I usually make birthday cakes myself but didn't have it in me this year for my son's second birthday! Frost My Heart by far exceeded my expectations! Looks beautiful and I can't wait to taste it!!!"
- Sara Gresh
"FMH has awesome cupcakes and I love how she offers cash n carry specials. It always seems to be at a perfect time."
- Liz Foreman
"Karla designed a cake and sugar-free cupcakes for my dad-it was beautiful! Such a happy customer! Sweet lady who makes beautiful sweet treats! Highly recommended!"
- Michelle Gerfen
"FMH is our go to for baked goods! Karla makes a delicious product that looks as good as it tastes! My daughter won't eat cake or cupcakes but she LOVES FMH cake balls."
- Debbie Collett
"I was very pleased [with the cake]. Everyone loved it. When it is time for another cake, I will be ordering from Frost My Heart."
- Trinka Glenn
 
"Our cake was perfect, beyond our expectations, it looked beautiful and tasted amazing. Guest were asking for seconds."
- Denise Knox
 
"Karla made a beautiful Care Bear cake for our daughter's birthday. I usually do not care for buttercream icing, but this icing was great and the cake was so moist. Everyone loved it. Not to mention the creative design! We would highly recommend FMH for your baking needs! Thanks, Karla!"
- Scott Stewart